165 Bay Avenue · Highlands, New Jersey

Not 2 Shabby Thrift, a thrift store in Highlands, NJ

Unique finds, always affordable. A family-owned, donation-based thrift shop on the corner of Bay & Miller, where every rack tells a story. Come see what's new.

Plan a visit → @not2shabby_thrift

The Not 2 Shabby Thrift storefront at 165 Bay Avenue, Highlands NJ, lit up at night for its one-year anniversary — 165 Bay Ave ♡

Browse

Fresh off the rack.

Real finds, photographed on our floor. The racks turn over constantly, so what you see here is a taste. The good stuff goes fast. drag to browse →

Navy Yankees varsity jacket with patches — OuterwearPatched Yankees varsity

Green heart-checker knit sweater — KnitwearHeart-checker sweater

Tan leather shoulder bag — BagsDesigner bags, thrift prices

Classic denim jacket on a hanger — DenimThe forever jean jacket

Green and black Nike sneaker — SneakersSneaker Saturday staples

Silver glitter stiletto held up in the store — ShoesFlats to heels

Cut crystal pitchers on a shelf — HouseholdCut crystal & glassware

Pink cable cardigan — KnitwearCardigan weather

Bright New Balance running shoe — SneakersPops of color

Shelf of Sarah J. Maas fantasy novels — Books & moviesYour next binge

Hot pink velvet top — TopsVelvet, obviously

Drag or use the arrows

Shop the floor online.

Can’t make it to Bay Ave? Our favorite pieces are online too. One of a kind, so when it’s gone, it’s gone.

$10$100

Bags & accessoriesBlack Leather Gloves with Yellow Accents

Shop everything →

A little shop with a big heart.

— the N2S family

Family owned. Donation based. Highlands through and through.

Not 2 Shabby opened its doors in October 2025 on the corner of Miller Street and Bay Avenue, run by the Villali family. No ribbon, no ceremony on day one, just a line of neighbors ready to try on jackets and dig for treasure.

Everything on the floor is donated by our community or collected by the family: clothing, shoes, bags, jewelry, toys, holiday décor, furniture, and household goods. Gently used, sometimes brand new with tags, always priced so you can say yes.

And when you shop here, part of every sale goes right back into the Bayshore.

2025Est. in Highlands

100%Donation based

10%Profits given back

Ribbon cutting ceremony in front of Not 2 Shabby Thrift with neighbors and the N2S family — ribbon cutting day ✂︎

It means so much to our N2S family to see the way the Highlands community has welcomed us with open arms.— Not 2 Shabby, after the ribbon cutting

More than just a thrift.

We rotate the causes we support so the whole Bayshore, from Highlands to Keyport, feels it. Here's where your purchases have gone.

The N2S giving ledgerPaid forward

A share of profits, every season
A portion of proceeds goes to a local charity, with a new recipient each rotation. 10% of profits at opening.
10%
American Legion & VFW
Our very first recipients, chosen in honor of Veterans Day the month we opened.
first ♥
Area food pantries
Next up in the rotation, keeping Bayshore families fed.
next up
Good Counsel Homes
A proud partner. Each month we gather and donate clothes and essentials for new and expectant mothers and their babies. Have something to give? Drop it off during business hours. @goodcounselhomes
monthly
Waters & Sims
We collaborate with local organizations to give their causes exposure and create opportunities for all. @waters_and_sims
partners
The community board
Own a local business? Drop off your cards or flyers and we'll pin them up in the shop. Supporting small is always in style.
free!

Artisan of the Month.

Every month we hand a corner of the shop to a local maker. Their handmade work sits right next to the racks, available that month only.

January2026

Short Cuts

Handcrafted maple, padauk and koto cutting boards from Sean Slattery, a chef with a woodworker's hands.

February2026

Autumn's Cabin Creations

Hand-painted jewelry, ornaments, tree toppers, decals and etched glass.

@autumnscabincreations ↗

March2026

Let Love Resinate

Functional resin art: glasses, mini dishes, key chains and ocean-blue everything.

@letloveresinate ↗

May2026

jewels

Jewels by Jewel

Handmade jewelry, just in time for Mother's Day, graduations and summer.

@jewels.jewels.at.deo ↗

June2026

art

Shore Shart

Local art, featured in the shop for the month of June.

@shore_shart ↗

July2026

gems

Marisol Gemz

Handmade gem jewelry with a little extra sparkle.

Make something beautiful? We'd love to feature you.

DM us on Instagram →

Inside Not 2 Shabby: racks of clothing, toys and shelves under a pressed-tin ceiling

Psst — the secret's out

Rosey's Rummage Room

Tucked inside N2S is the room where the real steals are. Amazing finds and unbeatable prices. Stop by and see what hidden gems you can score before they're gone.

🌹Hidden gems · unbeatable prices

Give it a second life.

Everything on our floor comes from people like you. Donations are loved and welcomed, as long as we're there to say thank you in person.

Donation drop-off pass

Clothing & outerwear
Shoes, bags & accessories
Household & home décor
Toys, books & movies
Drop off during open hours
Or call ahead to schedule
Please don't leave items outside after hours

Schedule a drop-off (917)
750-4637 admit one good deed Book a time →

Straight from the 'gram.

New drops, Sneaker Saturdays, holiday sales and the artisan reveal all hit Instagram first. Follow along so you never miss a find.

window shopping

St. Patrick's Day mannequin display — erin go bragh ☘︎

Community Matters board with local business cards — community matters

Wall of thrifted handbags — galentine's spree

Rack of neutral cardigans — new arrivals

Inside the shop for the Good Counsel Homes donation drive — for moms & babies

Shop doorway with a support local caption — support local

@not2shabby_thrift

Follow on Instagram ↗Facebook ↗

Neighbors say it best.

5.0★★★★★27 Google reviews

Read them on Google ↗Leave a review

Come say hi.

Right on Bay Avenue in downtown Highlands, a few minutes from Sandy Hook. Free parking lot on Bay Ave.

N2S

NOT 2 SHABBY THRIFT
165 BAY AVE · HIGHLANDS NJ
(917) 750-4637

FALL / WINTER HOURS

TOTAL SAVINGSPRICELESS

DONATIONSACCEPTED

GIFT CARDSAVAILABLE

*** THANK YOU ***

Hours change with the seasons and for holidays. Check Instagram for the latest before you head over.

Find us165 Bay Avenue
Highlands, NJ 07732

Corner of Bay Ave & Miller St.

Call the shop(917) 750-4637

Questions, holds, or scheduling a donation drop-off.

N2S · Bay Ave

★★★★★Loved your visit?Leave us a Google review. It helps neighbors find us and means the world to a small family shop. Leave a Google review →

Good to know.

Quick answers about shopping, donating and finding us in Highlands.

Where is Not 2 Shabby Thrift located?

We're at 165 Bay Avenue in downtown Highlands, NJ 07732, on the corner of Bay Avenue and Miller Street, a few minutes from Sandy Hook. There's a free parking lot on Bay Ave.

What are Not 2 Shabby Thrift's hours?

Fall/winter hours: Thursday 11 AM to 7 PM, Friday 11 AM to 6 PM, Saturday 11 AM to 5 PM and Sunday 1 PM to 5 PM. We're closed Monday through Wednesday. Hours change with the seasons and for holidays, so check our Instagram, @not2shabby_thrift, before you head over.

Do you accept donations?

Yes. We take clothing and outerwear; shoes, bags and accessories; household goods and home décor; and toys, books and movies. Drop them off during open hours, or call (917) 750-4637 to schedule a drop-off. Please don't leave items outside after hours.

What can I find at Not 2 Shabby?

Women's, men's and kids' clothing, sneakers and shoes, designer bags, jewelry, furniture, household goods, holiday décor, books and movies, toys and more. Everything is gently used or new with tags and priced to be affordable. Don't miss Rosey's Rummage Room inside the shop.

Does shopping at Not 2 Shabby support local charities?

Yes. A portion of profits goes to a local charity, with a new recipient each rotation. Our first recipients were the American Legion and VFW, and area food pantries are next. We also collect clothes and essentials every month for Good Counsel Homes, which supports new and expectant mothers and their babies.

Do you sell gift cards?

Yes, Not 2 Shabby gift cards are available in the shop.

Can I shop online?

Yes. Browse our online shop for one-of-a-kind pieces, check out securely with a card, Apple Pay or Google Pay, and choose shipping or free local pickup at the shop.

Can local makers sell at Not 2 Shabby?

Every month our Artisan of the Month program gives a corner of the shop to a local maker. If you make something beautiful, send us a DM on Instagram.

First dibs on new drops.

New arrivals, drop days and sales, straight to your inbox. No spam, just good finds.

Hunting for something specific?

Tell us what you’re looking for and we’ll email you the moment one hits the racks.

Not 2 Shabby Thrift, a thrift store in Highlands, NJ N2S Not 2 Shabby THRIFT